What does it tell us about how deluded white southerners had become about slavery?

The first file is an excerpt from the writings of George Fitzhugh, a famous antebellum southern intellectual, in which he responds to the abolitionist attacks on slavery. In a couple of paragraphs, sum up and analyze his logic and argument. What does it tell us about how deluded white southerners had become about slavery? Also, do you notice him make a point that actually undermines his argument without him seeming to realize it?
Once slave owners began to respond like this to abolitionists, the abolitionist ramped up their publications to prove their points, the most effective of which were more and more memoirs from runaway slaves. The second linked file is an excerpt from one of them, in which Josiah Henson describes the biggest memory from his childhood. In a couple of paragraphs, sum up the events he explains, focusing on how it helps illustrate some of the points from our class lecture on Antebellum slavery.
Lastly, having read this two different perspectives on slavery, I would like to hear your thoughts and reflections on these two documents. You can go in any direction with this that you’d like, but focus on your personal thoughts.
Answer & Explanation
VerifiedSolved by verified expert
George Fitzhugh’s logic and argument is that slavery is not only not bad for slaves, but is actually good for them. He argues that slaves are better off than poor white people because they have food and shelter provided for them, and they don’t have to worry about working to earn a living. He also argues that slavery is a natural state, and that it

Looking for a similar assignment?

Let Us write for you! We offer custom paper writing services

Place your order

Step-by-step explanation
is only abolitionists who are trying to make it look bad. However, his argument is undermined by the fact that he admits that slaves are not treated equally to whites, and that they are not given the same opportunities. This shows that even he recognizes that there is something inherently wrong with slavery.

Josiah Henson’s account of his childhood illustrates some of the points from our class lecture on Antebellum slavery. He describes how he was taken from his mother at a young age, and how he was beaten and mistreated by his owners. He also describes how he eventually ran away and found freedom. His story helps to illustrate the cruelty of slavery, and how it was often experienced by slaves.

Latest Assignment